Was Susannah Goddard really Thomas?

Thomas Goddard was the father of Frederick Goddard (baptised on 26th Janurary 1813 in Newtimber, see earlier post).¹ He married Emma Frankland in St Nicholas Brighton on 10th December 1809.² The couple baptised three children in Newtimber (Frederick plus Eliza 1810 and Michael 1815) before moving to Brighton where Thomas Goddard of Newtimber died, aged 30, and was buried in St Nicholas’ Churchyard on 23rd October 1817.³ A posthumous child, Thomas, was baptised on 21st June 1818 in St Nicholas Brighton, with the abode stated to be Richmond Row (later part of Albion Hill).⁴

St Nicholas of Myra, Brighton, photographed by the author 11th July 2016

Emma remarried (at St Nicholas, to Francis Buckle on 29th January 1822) one of the witnesses being Richard Goddard (son of William Goddard & Susannah Peacock baptised in Newtimber on 3rd April 1791).⁵ After initially living in Albourne, Richard Goddard and his wife Sarah baptised two children in St Nicholas Brighton in 1819 & 1822 while living in Richmond Row.⁶ Coincidence or a close family link?

William Goddard & Susannah did not baptise a child named Thomas though there is a baptism for Susanna in 1787. However William had an illegitimate nephew, Thomas son of his sister Sarah baptised 29 Jan 1769 in Newtimber.⁷ This Thomas would have been 48+ when Thomas Goddard of Newtimber was buried in Brighton. This is a big difference from the 30 years old of the burial register and considering that Emma Frankland was literate, signing her name in both marriage entries, it is hard to see how this big a mistake could be made.⁸

St John the Evangelist, Newtimber, photographed by the author 10th July 2016

I was able to track five of the six children to the grave, four of them through marriage(s) and children, but nothing for Susanna! (See Table.)⁹ All those who survived long enough can be found in all censuses up to their deaths.

The documented offspring of William and Susannah Goddard plus Thomas

Name	Baptism	Marriage	Children	Buried
Sarah	24 Jun 1783	5 Jul 1803	Frances (1803), William (1805), Thomas (1806), Susan (1808, Mary Anne (1810), James (1816), John (1821)	30 Mar 1860
William	7 Oct 1784	7 Apr 1817	William (1818), Thomas (1820), Henry (1822), George (1824), Ann (1826), Sarah (1828), Jane (1830), James (1831), Mary (1833), Hannah (1835), Eliza (1837), Frederick (1839)	26 Nov 1854
Susanna	4 Oct 1787
John	6 Sep 1789	6 Apr 1812; 11 Apr 1830	John (1812), William (1814), Walter (1820), Richard Henry (1830), Mary Jane (1832), Elizabeth (1838), James (1839), Sarah (1842)	3 Dec 1876
Richard	3 Apr 1791	22 Jun 1810	James (1810), Mary (1812), Fanny (1815), Thomas (1816), William (1819), John (1822), Elizabeth (1823), Ann (1827)	died 31 Aug 1870
James	11 Sep 1796			22 Aug 1815
Thomas		10 Dec 1809	Eliza (1810), Frederick (1813), Michael (1815), Thomas (1818)	23 Oct 1817

Did Susanna die during the period when the Newtimber registers were not properly kept (see earlier blog post)? Or was the name misinterpreted when transcribed into the register? In the baptism entry for Sarah her mother’s name was also given as “Sarah” (a not uncommon error in parish register entries). The error was repeated for William’s baptism but corrected (faintly).¹⁰ So whoever was keeping the register was not careful. In the notes used to initially record a baptism, given names were often abbreviated. Susannah was usually abbreviated Sh and Thomas was sometimes abbreviated Th. Cursive capital S’s and T’s can be misread (I’ve done it myself). So if the cleric knew the mother’s name was Susanna(h) and misread Th as Sh, he could easily mistranscribe the given name as “Susanna”.

Baptism entries of Sarah and William Goddard¹⁰

The only further supporting evidence I have for this is a DNA connection between my father and a descendent of Susannah Peacock’s great-grandparents at Thakefield (Thomas Peacock and Rose Vaughan).¹¹

Sources

1.  St John the Evangelist (Newtimber, Sussex, England), "West Sussex Record Office PAR429/1/1/4, Register of Baptisms 1808-1813," page 3, baptism of Frederick Goddard, 26 Jan 1813; FHL microfilm 991,065, item 2.3
2. St Nicholas (Brighton, Sussex, England), "East Sussex Record Office PAR255/1/1/11, Register of Banns & Marriages 1806-1810," page 138, marriage of Thomas Goddard & Emma Frankland, 10 Dec 1809; FHL microfilm 1,067,106, item 2.
3. St John the Evangelist (Newtimber, Sussex, England), "West Sussex Record Office, PAR429/1/1/4 Register of Baptisms 1808-1813," page 2, baptism of Eliza Goddard, 4 Oct 1810; FHL microfilm 991,065, item 2.3; St John the Evangelist (Newtimber, Sussex, England), "West Sussex Record Office PAR429/1/2/-, Register of Baptisms 1813-1877," page 2, baptism of Michael Goddard, 30 Dec 1815; FHL microfilm 991,065, item 2.4; St Nicholas (Brighton, Sussex, England), "East Sussex Record Office Ref PAR255/1/5/2, Register of Burials 1816-1822," page 76, burial of Thomas Goddard, 23 Oct 1817; FHL microfilm 1,067,169, item 5
4. St Nicholas (Brighton, Sussex, England), Parish Registers, "East Sussex Record Office PAR2551/2/2, St Nicholas Brighton Register of Baptisms 1816-1820 (Folder 004427381, Item 1),"  page 172, baptism of Thomas Goddard, 21 Jun 1818; digital images, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ : accessed 21 Feb 2016)
5. St Nicholas (Brighton, Sussex, England), "East Sussex Record Office Ref PAR155/1/3/3, Register of Marriages 1820-1823," page 177, marriage of Francis Buckle & Emma Goddard, 9 Jan 1822; FHL microfilm 1,067,115, item 2; St John the Evangelist (Newtimber, Sussex, England), "West Sussex Record Office PAR 429/1/1/2, General Register 1733-1808," baptism of Richard Goddard, 3 Apr 111791; FHL microfilm 991,065, item 2.2; St John the Evangelist (Newtimber, Sussex, England), "West Sussex Record Office PAR 429, Register of Marriages & Banns 1754-1848," marriage of William Godard & Susan Peacock, 29 Jan 1783; FHL microfilm 991,065, item 2.5.
6. Baptisms of William (1819) & John (1822) Goddard, Sussex Family History Group, "Sussex Baptisms," database, Sussex Family History Group Data Archive (http://sfhg.frontis.co/bin/index.php)
7. St John the Evangelist (Newtimber, Sussex, England), "West Sussex Record Office PAR 429/1/1/2, General Register 1733-1808," baptism of Thomas Goddard, 29 Jan 1769; FHL microfilm 991,065, item 2.2
8. St Nicholas (Brighton, Sussex, England), "East Sussex Record Office PAR255/1/1/11, Register of Banns & Marriages 1806-1810," page 138, marriage of Thomas Goddard & Emma Frankland, 10 Dec 1809; St Nicholas (Brighton, Sussex, England), "East Sussex Record Office Ref PAR155/1/3/3, Register of Marriages 1820-1823," page 177, marriage of Francis Buckle & Emma Goddard, 9 Jan 1822
9. Sussex Family History Group, "Sussex Baptisms," database, Sussex Family History Group Data Archive (http://sfhg.frontis.co/bin/index.php); Sussex Family History Group, editor, CD-ROM (Lewes, England: Sussex Family History Group, 2005); Sussex Family History Group, "Sussex Burials," database, Sussex Family History Group Data Archive (http://sfhg.frontis.co/bin/index.php)    
10. St John the Evangelist (Newtimber, Sussex, England), "West Sussex Record Office PAR 429/1/1/2, General Register 1733-1808," baptism of Sarah Goddard, 24 Jun 1783; FHL microfilm 991,065, item 2.2; St John the Evangelist (Newtimber, Sussex, England), "West Sussex Record Office PAR 429/1/1/2, General Register 1733-1808," baptism of William Goddard, 17 Oct 1784; FHL microfilm 991,065, item 2.2.
11. AncestryDNA Results for Alfred Commons, "Ancestry Australia" database, Ancestry Australia (https://www.ancestry.com.au/ : accessed 8 Mar 2020), DNA match with Jan Thompson (managed by Malandjan)